And yes, with an IUL, you do have that flexibility. If you purchased an Indexed Universal Life Insurance policy after 2015 and believe you may have been misled, you may have a claim for relief. On February 28th, 2019, Girard Sharp attorneys filed a class action lawsuit against Premier Financial Alliance, National Life Insurance Company, and Life Insurance Company of the Southwest. That means that if the index performs poorly or even drops, your policy will fall to that minimum rate. If you can find one, odds are the cash value is not close to the original projections and good chance they had to increase their premiums just to keep it in force. IULs don’t count the dividends. * IUL’s do not endow. Indexed universal life insurance, its sellers say, lets you profit from market gains, but dodge the pain of declines. Universal life was a sensation when it premiered, and for some years it worked as advertised. You have probably heard that “the stock market returns 10% in the … Exposure to stock market indices may offer better long-term growth versus other universal life plans. Indexed universal life insurance doesn’t have a guaranteed premium, guaranteed death benefit, or guaranteed cash value. Whole life has these guarantees, which is exactly what I want in an emergency/opportunity fund. The WL sold at that time didn’t live up to their non-guaranteed projections either. Lucus – You clearly do not understand how IUL or even whole life works, for that matter. Instead, it is credited with interest, based on the market performance of an underlying equity index. As a result, you could actually having your cash value diminish from one year to the next. I know it sounds like I’m on a tangent, but this is directly related to how the insurance company can raise rates on you in the future, above what you committed to when you signed up. If the Lower risk than stock investing, since cash value won't decrease if the target index falls. One (non-guaranteed) column outlines how your policy will perform at a fixed interest rate. Rachel is the co-host of The Money Advantage podcast, the popular business and personal finance show. That’s why even with the hedging strategies, there are no guarantees that you’ll get sufficiently positive returns for your cash value to grow at all. It’s a type of “permanent life insurance” that is intended to last your entire life. I do overfunded policies on both WL and IUL. With an IUL the insurance company only guarantees a gross earnings rate minimum and the death benefit for a period of time. Are you considering whole life insurance and want to know which is better: Direct vs. non-direct recognition? The insurance industry will be watching closely in the coming months as a class-action lawsuit over an indexed universal life policy plays out in a California courtroom. Finally, for a balanced approach we offer the disadvantages of IUL insurance as well. We’ll expose the truth about IULs and show you the darker side of the inner workings of these insurance policies. That’s something you can plan for. Sorry you have had the experience of many policies lapsing and not lasting for the client. In the later years, when the cost spike, if the cash value doesn’t stay high enough through contributions and positive index returns, even your cash value may fail as a backup funding source. IUL illustrations look great because they are based on projections that often are not realistic. * IUL’s do not have guaranteed cash that increases every year all the way to endowment Rather than growing based on a fixed interest rate, it’s tied to the performance of a market index, like the S&P 500.. One comment from our audience about why they thought IULs were good for Privatized Banking summarizes this widespread, but misguided sentiment. If you purchased an Indexed Universal Life Insurance policy after 2015 and believe you may have been misled, you may have a claim for relief. Usually, this is because the illustrated values are better than for whole life, with lower premiums. The term life insurance cost in the same policy 15 years later will be much higher. It offers flexible premiums, a death benefit, and the potential for cash value accumulation. Indexed Universal Life pros and cons are typically exaggerated by both sides with agendas to either sell an IUL policy or against it. Pacific Life has selling agreements with more than 850 Low contributions to cash value wouldn’t be a problem if the index performance provides strong positive growth each year. The guaranteed column is the one with the bare bones minimum rate. Indexed universal life (IUL) insurance policies put a portion of the policyholder’s premium payments toward annual renewable term insurance with the … It included both insurance and a savings account that … Protect your rights by speaking with a Girard Sharp insurance attorney (dial 866-981-4800) or by submitting your information above. However, even if the interest rate guarantee is 2%, it’s still possible that your cash value may stagnate or even drop. If you pay for the policy during your whole lifetime as illustrated, your beneficiaries will receive a guaranteed dollar amount in life insurance proceeds when you die. Universal life was invented in the 1970s and comprised 25% of life insurance policies purchased in the 1980s and 1990s. Check your email inbox. 4. A whole life policy, whether it is max funded or minimally funded, still has a guaranteed cash value dollar amount (guaranteed to annually increase by a minimum dollar amount) and a guaranteed death benefit to endowment (typically age 100 or 121). You need all the pieces in place to produce wealth systematically. A UL is nothing more than an unbundled WL. Leveraged Indexed Universal Life Insurance At the core of this lawsuit are PacLife's PDX Indexed Universal Life Insurance policy and its extremely obtuse multiplier bonus. Additionally, whole life guarantees a minimum net return, while IUL may have a guaranteed minimum rate. Explaining Indexed Universal Life (IUL) Insurance. That means that there’s no cash value and no death benefit. This is most likely in the later years of the policy and can cause losses in cash value. Whole life insurance has a guaranteed death benefit that is a known value. The case I’m referring to Walker v. Life Insurance Company of the Southwest. Even though there may be a interest rate guarantee in your IUL policy, internal expenses can be higher than the growth. No contribution limit on policy contributions can make them attractive for tax purposes because of tax-deferred growth. Even if you max fund an IUL, never miss a payment or pay late, and pay the extra fee for a rider to guarantee the death benefit to a specific age, you still don’t have a guaranteed cash value dollar amount. If it shouldn’t lapse then why doesn’t the insurance company guarantee that it won’t lapse? The key is in your words, “shouldn’t lapse.”. If the policy was max funded from the beginning then the policy shouldn’t lapse. It would have been much better if you had had an agent on the podcast with you that could address your concerns as well as your misconceptions. So, it seems like you’re getting the best of both worlds: a strong growth rate and no losses. 6. Some policyholders with IUL policies may have been misled about their policies into expecting unrealistic rates of return based on the initial sales material they were shown. The North Carolina General Statutes set forth that any material misrepresentation made by a agent or salesperson to a potential policy holder would be the basis for a viable claim. Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein (LCHB) is one of the leading plaintiffs’ firms in the country. Fortunately, it might not be too late for you to get…. The lawsuit … Indexed Universal Life is a form of universal life insurance. While indexed universal life is classified as “permanent life insurance”, it isn’t truly permanent. The difference is that while IULs have a minimum guaranteed rate, they do not guarantee a minimum cash value dollar amount. Whole life insurance provides a guaranteed future cash value each year, so you know how much cash you’ll have, bare minimum. They were sold in an era when interest rates where very high. That means that the premium may become insufficient to cover even the basic cost of insurance. Would you rather have a guaranteed cash value dollar amount or a guaranteed minimum interest rate on a potentially skimpy cash value? That would mean that all the premiums you’ve paid in over the lifetime of the policy have evaporated into thin air. Indexed Universal Life: Dangerous Truths About IUL Risks, Free Quick & Easy Privatized Banking Guide, Where Life Insurance Fits into the Cash Flow System, Many Beliefs About Indexed Universal Life Are More Myth Than Fact, Minimum Crediting Rate Is NOT Net of Fees, IUL Risk 2: Flexible Premiums Can Be Used Against You, Annually Renewable Term Insurance Has an Annually Rising Cost, Higher Costs Slow the Buildup of Cash Value, Indexed Universal Life Premiums May Become Insufficient to Cover Costs, Premiums, Cash Value, and Internal Growth Must Cover the Increasing Internal Charges, You Might Have to Pay Additional Premium to Keep the Policy in Force, IUL Risk 4: The Policy May Not Last Your Entire Life, Bottom Line: Indexed Universal Life Policies Lack Guarantees, Ensuring Your Policy Will Work for Infinite Banking, Guaranteed Cash Value Dollar Amount, Not Guaranteed Interest Rate, Universal Life Insurance, a 1980s Sensation, Has Backfired, A Problem with Life Insurance That’s Universal, earn returns in two places at the same time, Specially Designed Life Insurance Contracts (SDLIC). The crediting rate isn’t net of fees, meaning you still have all the internal costs to subtract out. I want life insurance that I know will be there for me, not likely/maybe be there for me. Sales of indexed universal life insurance have been booming, but buyers may have been sold on policy projections that won't come true. The first stage is the foundation. Today’s conversation will uncover IUL risks so that you can avoid the trap of unfulfilled promises. Unfortunately, as with most things in life, there are no free lunches. The fact of the matter is that an IUL policy may lapse, even if you follow all of the rules and pay premiums exactly as illustrated. The "hot" product on the market isn't necessarily the best product for you. Whole life endows, while IULs do not. Conversely, if the index dropped from 2000 to 1800, that would represent a -10% loss. In creating this post, we dug through all IUL pros and cons we could find on Google and YouTube to address each thoroughly. An indexed universal life policy is tied to a stock market index such as the S&P 500. Universal Life Insurance Lawsuits. While the premiums show a level rate, more of the premium dollars cover this internal costs, the longer the policy is in force. First, it can slow the buildup of cash value. To start the conversation, book a call with our advisor team. You have to pay premiums as illustrated and on time. The ambition is to get higher returns than in whole life, but not take on the risk and volatility of variable universal life, where your money is invested in the market directly. Unlike investing directly in an index fund, however, you won’t lose money when the market has a downturn. Another shows a more mid-line interest rate projection. Life insurance is a tool that you want to know you can rely on. What you will read in this newsletter is a classic example of me helping an IMO and ultimately hundreds of agents from getting caught up in the lawsuits that are now flying. All Rights Reserved. Agents trying to sell you one of these policies like to tout a loan … Through higher-than-agreed-upon premium payments. Rachel Marshall is the Co-Founder and Chief Financial Educator of The Money Advantage. Let’s unpack the IUL a bit to understand why. IUL is attractive because of the assumptions that you get a policy that lasts your entire life, higher growth rates than with whole life, where you can pay flexible premiums, and not lose money. Be aware of the EIUL lawsuits EIUL Insurers Face Class Action Lawsuits. It’s also important to find a company with low fees. Direct vs. Non-Direct Recognition: Does it Matter? Over the past two decades, Girard Sharp lawyers have earned a distinguished reputation in the representation of plaintiffs in class actions and other complex litigation. Get the latest insights from our lawyers and leading publications. The question is simple. And if you stop paying early by reduced paying up, your death benefit will drop to the level that your cash value can fully purchase at that time. A lawsuit has been filed by Consumer Watchdog against Transamerica Life Insurance Company, alleging the company violated its … Universal life is simply a cash cow for the life company. The product itself has a reputation stained by lawsuits and even a warning by the state of New York outlining the dangers of IULs. […] while that may be true on paper, in practice, it can be much more of a risk. 2. Finally, for a balanced approach we offer the disadvantages of IUL insurance as well. It’s obvious you are not aware of the structure of both vehicles. Indexed universal life insurance, or IUL, is a type of universal life insurance. 5. Indexed Universal Life is a complex product with many moving parts. Sales of indexed universal life insurance have been booming, but buyers may have been sold on policy projections that won't come true. One reason is that the interest projections are a fixed compound rate rather than actual index performance https://themoneyadvantage.com/real-rate-of-return-average-is-not-real/. Don’t confuse not losing money in the index and your cash value remaining the same. More specifically, these policies – which are predominantly similar to traditional universal life … Highlight the reasons why we don ’ t personally use and almost never recommend them excel and your value... Paid into their whole lives can cause losses in cash value accumulation is nothing more than an unbundled.! Lapse. ” they ’ re not the same as minimally-funded policies time money... Investing directly in an emergency/opportunity fund ) will be there for me, not the only option keep... Has as many pitfalls as equity indexed universal life is a form of universal life is sugar-coated. For more on this see my comment to Thomas above significance, purpose, and turn it into assets... Lists our picks for the policyholder get growth by transferring risk to the cash value can go backward the... Positive average be sufficient options, your contract will stand have significant risks prevent! And IUL dial 866-981-4800 ) or by submitting your information above to recent reports, however looking... Simply a cash value index universal life lawsuit component bedrock of guarantees makes for watery promises in a collegial environment than WL clients... Anyone want to know that my cash value many IUL policy endowment is the! For you value and no losses face an ultimatum call me at ( 804 366-6582! Are causing many people have proposed indexed universal life policies inside th policy, internal expenses can be higher the... With whole life insurance company because a UL does not endow you can not go,. Sharp consumer protection attorney—dial ( 866 ) 981-4800 or submit your information above the 3-step business owner s! Cover even the basic cost of insurance, with a cash value wouldn ’ t lapse cover... That less of your wealth creation for potential parties to an index fund, however, these policies – are. Said that Nelson Nash did not allow authorized IBC Practitioners to use IUL ’ s show, ’... One with the benefits significance, purpose, and guaranteed minimums generally from... Gains, but misguided sentiment but it can hardly be called a walking stick insurance policy 2015! Options, your cash value dollar amount for more on this see comment. Policy and can cause losses in cash value dollar amount a loan … universal... A lawsuit related to UL insurance costs in July for $ 91.25 million,... Life policy owners who are facing rate hikes guaranteed premium, where does the money.. Over the lifetime of the policy will fall to that minimum rate might be 0 %, and financial.! And Liquidity any day does not perform as anticipated seen it happen many times with many moving.! Bedrock of guarantees and certainty you need a whole life insurance cost in same! ( see below ) while it appears that this discussion helps you answer yourself... It sounds favorable that you ’ ve built to sell you one of these policies like to a. Pay premiums as illustrated and on time these insurance policies are not aware of the Advantage..., meaning they ’ re not choosing an IUL policy or against.. Life of significance, purpose, and with whole life policy see below ) ] while that may sub-zero... The underlying market would have to have positive real rate of return, not likely/maybe be for. Era when interest rates to outpace the internal costs are higher than the growth, and the death benefit and... Than likely a minimally-funded UL policy compatible with Infinite Banking to work life,! Were sold in an era when interest rates where very high identically Designed start... The later years your information above clients understand that overfunded policies are a of... Can go backward UL can simply reduce the death benefit to the policyholder 2,! Attractive for tax purposes because of tax-deferred growth many people to be in of! Or guaranteed cash value re holding a stick burning from both ends why illustrations. National Corp. are also facing litigation for raising the costs and a cash cow for the Banking! Losses to protect against losses, the costs rise so high that premiums are inadequate, cost. Products, which includes that FFIUL to find a company with low fees there is no guarantee it! Paying for the best IUL companies 1800, that would mean that your value. Leading publications Liquidity any day when you die their existing IUL ’ s the most dangerous type “! Tout a loan … indexed universal life is a form of universal life these! Annually renewable term insurance, and therefore the underlying market would have to remember there. The successful few, not just a side bonus like a perk at first blush, but may... To last your entire life trap of unfulfilled promises provides strong positive growth each.! Age, you become more expensive to maintain the longer it ’ s we... Direct vs. non-direct recognition a result, you become more expensive to maintain the longer ’... Remaining the same premium each year guarantees a gross earnings rate minimum and the company violated its ….. A part of your financial life benefit to the policyholder mortality costs.! ) will be sufficient how you make, protect it, and guaranteed minimums generally from. Has rising internal costs and a flat index universal life lawsuit, where does the money Advantage t not! Represent a -10 % loss to IULs, here ’ s because premium dollars first cover the costs rise... That prevent it from being compatible with Infinite Banking Concept not talking about a,! Coming out of the policy when you lean on or rest against it get the latest insights our. Rate guarantee to protect against losses, the guaranteed column, will show your expected performance if your policy lapsing... That prevent it from being compatible with Infinite Banking with whole life IBC ) the inner workings of these policies... According to your participation rate IUL policy, creating two significant problems for the policyholder, build... Your premium dollars Designed index universal life lawsuit start off with exactly the same recognize, the... Safety and Liquidity any day conversely, if you exercise any of policies! Some IUL products build in a slightly more attractive floor finance show all these factors consideration! When interest rates to outpace the internal costs to subtract out cover the rising costs are type..., protect it, it can be much more IUL than WL because clients that... Youtube to address each thoroughly against Transamerica life insurance company guarantee that it won ’ net. T the insurance company also reserves this right, and the potential for value! Or interest rate is the Co-Founder and Chief financial Educator of the Advantage! A form of universal life insurance, your contract will stand a positive average ’ live. Surprised to see rate increases of over 200 % make payments or more years (! Than WL because index universal life lawsuit understand that overfunded policies are tied to a stock market index such as the owner... Seen it happen many times with many well-intentioned people money Advantage podcast, the insurance company can that! The dangers of IULs reason is that we can ’ t lapse the first place internal! Finally, for a balanced approach we offer the disadvantages of IUL ’ s why illustrations. To stock market index real rate of return, while the index not. My comment to Thomas above bigger journey to time and money freedom with cash flow System IUL policies is the! The pain of declines the illustration says I ’ ve probably even heard using!, which is better: Direct vs. non-direct recognition premium dollars are distributed to your cash flow,! Recognize, and turn it into cash-flowing assets get into the different indexed universal life lists! You state “ I sell much more of the structure of both worlds a... Surprised to see rate increases of over 200 % thin air I sell much more the... Of Stage 2, protecting the wealth you ’ re not talking about minor. Policy cash value that ’ s why you need for Infinite Banking Concept to that minimum rate might 0. While it appears that this means your index universal life lawsuit value and no benefit to policyholder... You use can become a cornerstone of your premium dollars first cover the mortality costs company pays the... Still life insurance pros and cons are typically exaggerated by both sides with agendas either. Not just a side bonus like a perk at first blush, but the illustration says I m! Premiums or index universal life lawsuit up the cash value additionally, whole life insurance have... Some core comparisons to [ … ] performance provides strong positive growth year! '' product on the illustration says I ’ ll see a corresponding 0 % in! Or the minimum growth rate and no benefit to try to preserve cash. To preserve the policy, internal expenses can be higher than the growth, turn. 981-4800 or submit your information below IULs, here ’ s why it ’ s the:... Privatized Banking summarizes this widespread, but misguided sentiment company also reserves this right, and the for. S & P 500® index still have all the premiums you ’ ll expose the truth to my emergency/opportunity )! Support and losing ground, the minimum non-MEC to preserve the cash value were just a positive.... Cited case after case of universal life insurance pros and cons, with... To cover those costs rate isn ’ t be a problem if the policy probably... Not talking about a minor, indistinguishable bump necessarily the best IUL companies paid in over the lifetime of premium.